STL-After-Dark wrote:
Critique the person above you and post your best for the next person to critique.

Wow... I love the colors, and the textures are wonderful.  Nice mood with the model, almost looks storybook in style.  Only "negative" thing I have to say is I notice the crooked background.  Otherwise it's excellent!

And here's me...

TMA Photo wrote:

Wow... I love the colors, and the textures are wonderful.  Nice mood with the model, almost looks storybook in style.  Only "negative" thing I have to say is I notice the crooked background.  Otherwise it's excellent!

And here's me...

Wonderful ,location and day, love the light quality and you have used it well on the model.  good styling too.

mine

Lookinghooks wrote:
Ummmm...  None of you are n00bs.  Do you seriously not know this type of thread is limited to the critique forum, that critique is not permitted here?

They changed the critique forums rules.  So this is not considered a critique anymore, they consider it a game.  Go complain to Brian Diaz, Have Pentax will Travel, or Dean Johnson.

JM Studios wrote:
They changed the critique forums rules.  So this is not considered a critique anymore, they consider it a game.  Go complain to Brian Diaz, Have Pentax will Travel, or Dean Johnson.

Could you link us to this rule change?  Say something nice/mean about the way the person above you smells is fair game for OT/SF2.  When you move actual critique out of its appropriate forum to OT/SF2 it doesn't magically become a game, while real critique is being sought and given.

"Go complain to..." isn't a particularly constructive tone to take, now is it?

Lookinghooks wrote:

Could you link us to this rule change?  Say something nice/mean about the way the person above you smells is fair game for OT/SF2.  When you move actual critique out of its appropriate forum to OT/SF2 it doesn't magically become a game, while real critique is being sought and given.

"Go complain to..." isn't a particularly constructive tone to take, now is it?

https://www.modelmayhem.com/po.php?thread_id=437961

It is the proper tone, when it has been heavily debated and we told them this would happen if you move these types of critiques to other forums.  Read for yourself.