Forums > Digital Art and Retouching > DAR Critiques > Can you critique my retouch?

Retoucher

J9Design

Posts: 2

London, England, United Kingdom

Hi There,

I'm new to the site and to photo retouching, but it's an area that I am becoming more and more interested in.
I have retouched this image (image is courtesy of Chanel Rene).

https://modelmayhem.com/portfolio/pic/16584516][img]http://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/100226/08/4b87f7d5f048f_m.jpg

I could really do with someone who is more experienced than me having a look and telling me where I can improve so all criticisms/advice/opinions are welcome smile

Thanks in advance!

Feb 26 10 08:20 am Link

Retoucher

KKP Retouching

Posts: 1489

Anaheim, California, US

Her skin is still kinda blotchy, and that's especially noticeable from the contrasty processing you added.  Also, you need to be really careful about eyes- she now looks like she's not focusing on the lens, but rather something up and to her left.  If you're going to copy one eye and flip it, you need to manually switch the catch lights so they match the lighting.  It looks pasted on when lighting doesn't match a part of the image.

Instead, if you wanted to make that partially closed eye more open, I would have directly copied the iris from the other (so the catchlights say in place) and use liquify/warp/etc to reshape the original eyelid.

Feb 26 10 12:07 pm Link

Digital Artist

Koray

Posts: 6720

Ankara, Ankara, Turkey

I believe you mean this image:
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/100226/08/4b87f7d5f048f_m.jpg

I like how you made the skin shiny but you missed the eyes...she looks more cross eyed now with unnatural shapes..looks kinda funny though big_smile

Feb 26 10 12:09 pm Link

Retoucher

J9Design

Posts: 2

London, England, United Kingdom

Thanks for the replies smile

Koray, how did you manage to embed the photo? Still trying to figure that out.

KPP-Thanks for the suggestions for how to get around the eye problem. How would you go about fixing the skintone? I don't really want to go down the road of bluring as I think that can sometimes look really fake.

Thanks again for your help.

Mar 01 10 07:58 am Link

Digital Artist

Koray

Posts: 6720

Ankara, Ankara, Turkey

J9Design wrote:
Koray, how did you manage to embed the photo? Still trying to figure that out.

There is a box under each image here when viewed full size saying
MM Forum Code:
select all, copy, paste.

Mar 01 10 08:53 am Link

Photographer

Chanel Rene

Posts: 6780

Huntington Beach, California, US

Oooh lawd on those eyes! wink
Aside from that... I'm not crazy about the skin. But everyone has their own style I guess.

Mar 01 10 01:51 pm Link

Retoucher

Sebastian Reuter

Posts: 126

Frankfurt, Hassia, Germany

maybe you should just decrease the seize of the right and increase the size of the right eye a bit. it looks to me like you copied and flipped her right eye (the inner part big_smile ) which makes her look kinda weird.

Mar 02 10 02:25 am Link

Photographer

Ruben Sanchez

Posts: 3570

San Antonio, Texas, US

as I'm looking at her, when you changed the catchlight on the left side, it made her eyes look crossed.  The eyes are like mirrors, so what you see in one eye, should be same in the other eye.

Mar 02 10 02:41 am Link