Forums > Critique > Fun and Games > Scale of ( 1 - 100 ) on the person above you!

Photographer

Megan Gardner

Posts: 1027

New York, New York, US

50

Sep 17 16 06:13 pm Link

Photographer

Amul La La

Posts: 885

London, England, United Kingdom

Profile - 40-50

Portfolio - 70 - 80

Nov 22 16 01:20 am Link

Photographer

Buck Remington

Posts: 21

Beaverdam, Virginia, US

40 ish.  There's one or two that stand out, but mostly I see harsh lighting with too much contrast and wonky poses.  Perhaps try a few of those shots again on an overcast day.

Dec 02 16 07:34 pm Link

Model

Luna Diosa

Posts: 13242

Elizabeth, New Jersey, US

80

Dec 21 16 01:06 pm Link

Photographer

PPP Photo

Posts: 204

Naples, Campania, Italy

72

Great potential, though I don't like many works in your portfolio. I do prefer the dramatic side of you! You should be more selective, but it's just my poor opinion smile

Jan 05 17 12:37 am Link

Model

Meghan Congdon

Posts: 706

Austin, Texas, US

PPP Photo wrote:
72

Great potential, though I don't like many works in your portfolio. I do prefer the dramatic side of you! You should be more selective, but it's just my poor opinion smile

65. You have some really cool, artistic stuff in your portfolio!

Jan 05 17 08:11 am Link

Photographer

I Ference Photography

Posts: 1202

Brooklyn, New York, US

Meghan Congdon wrote:
65. You have some really cool, artistic stuff in your portfolio!

70.  Your port explains exactly what you want to do, and does it well.  Could use a bit more variation though (in terms of styles, backgrounds, etc).

Jan 05 17 12:26 pm Link

Model

MelissaTai

Posts: 42

New York, New York, US

I Ference Photography wrote:

70.  Your port explains exactly what you want to do, and does it well.  Could use a bit more variation though (in terms of styles, backgrounds, etc).

80 you have an interesting concept and some of the images are for a horror movie (good terms) , because of the angle of the shot

Jan 05 17 02:36 pm Link

Photographer

Kinky Vision

Posts: 22

New York, New York, US

70, You have a great look but your port is very limited.

Jan 06 17 12:39 am Link

Photographer

MrArt_Photography

Posts: 137

Miami, Florida, US

Kinky Vision  wrote:
70, You have a great look but your port is very limited.

65, I like some of your shots, but I think you can improve it  and create more amazing/ sexier shots , specially in the themes that you worked on

regards

pd: for who ever follows me. If I get a 35, I will be damn flattered , lol always learning always improving

Jan 07 17 02:01 pm Link

Model

Paola Duque

Posts: 118

Orlando, Florida, US

75 a sense of humor is beautiful along with image projection.

Jan 09 17 06:35 pm Link

Photographer

MrArt_Photography

Posts: 137

Miami, Florida, US

Paola Duque wrote:
75 a sense of humor is beautiful along with image projection.

pretty deep words, even thought I don't know if some of my shots made you go "LOL" 

Cheers preciosa

Jan 09 17 10:31 pm Link

Photographer

PPP Photo

Posts: 204

Naples, Campania, Italy

Should I reply to Paula Duque or MortArt?

In both case, I'm sorry to say I should rate 40, not more.

Both portfolio are lacking of charme, a style or an idea to develop. Technically good, but you both "just" show figures in a common way. Of course it's just my point of view

Feb 10 17 05:32 am Link

Photographer

I Ference Photography

Posts: 1202

Brooklyn, New York, US

PPP Photo wrote:

35.  Mainly because, while you have a few killer images in your port, most of it is dross.  If you pared your 70+ images down to 10 or 15 of your best - showing a range of good compositions, different lighting ideas, concepts, and so on, you could easily be somewhere in the 70s.  But this ain't that.  You have to wade through a lot of boring, or badly lit, or snapshotty photos to get to the good stuff - and that's going to turn a lot of people off.  Trim it down to the best of the best, and you could have a port that people really respond to.

Feb 13 17 02:12 pm Link

Model

Luna Diosa

Posts: 13242

Elizabeth, New Jersey, US

90! Still want to shoot with you patiently waiting popcorn lol

Feb 15 17 07:03 am Link

Photographer

Bureau Form Guild

Posts: 1244

Scranton, Pennsylvania, US

52

Jun 27 17 03:02 pm Link

Model

Nika Martin

Posts: 20

Miami, Florida, US

88+ loved some images !

Aug 31 17 05:03 pm Link