It's another "rate the person above you" game! The rules are simple - look at the person above you's portfolio and write three things about it.

1) Good - A positive comment about the person's work.

2) Bad - Tell someone politely what they can do to improve their work or portfolio.

3) Ugly - Wild card. Say anything you'd like about the person's work (as long as it's not extraordinarily rude or hurtful, don't be a dick). Whether it's a comment about something random in a specific photo, something unrelated the person's work reminds you of, or whatever else - it can be anything you like.

I guess it starts with me first.

Good: I like your "Art" approach to photography and some of your pictures clearly go into this direction

Bad: Some of your work doesn't connect with me. I just see "a picture", nothing else.

Ugly: Are you a beginner or new to photography? Seems like you have good idea but not the experience to realize them properly.

Hope that wasn't too harsh.