Forums > Critique > Serious Critique > Thoughts on this Photo... thanks.

Photographer

MC OConnor

Posts: 69

Asbury Park, New Jersey, US

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/170801/02/59804ecaa1689_m.jpg

Apr 09 18 05:28 pm Link

Model

Sandra Vixen

Posts: 1561

Las Vegas, Nevada, US

There is a bit too much green in the middle and doesn't fit any of the framing rules nicely.

That said it's okay, not really exciting but not boring, kind of somber but the framing is just uncomfortable.

Apr 10 18 04:12 pm Link

Photographer

Guss W

Posts: 10964

Clearwater, Florida, US

Don't be afraid to ask for an expression.

A distracting strap is showing.

The straight-on lighting is not giving the face much shape.

There are too many over-exposed areas.  Perhaps you were shooting at a high ISO, making it contrasty.

Maybe you intended the white area on the left to be a counterpoint to the white in the lower right, but I think the overall image would look better if you cropped off the white on the left, leaving the green background.

Apr 27 18 07:38 am Link

Photographer

Kris Krieg

Posts: 1341

Missoula, Montana, US

Good model selection. The editing needs improvement. The eyes and skin are over-processed. The whites of the eyes are too white and look unnatural. Eye color is too saturated as well. Her skin is too smooth and lacks detail. The white values of her wardrobe are blown out and losing detail. I think you are over-saturating your photos in general. Her skin tones appear to have way too much red and yellow in them. Plus, the background isn't really helping the image.

This shot is working better. Editing is much more natural.
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/120813/05/5028ecc94b1b3_m.jpg

Keep in mind that you are shooting a portrait. A horizontal composition is not the best choice for portraits. The human face and body are vertical in nature, so frame the subject vertically. Have the model take a couple steps away from the background in order to create a bit of background bokeh, creating depth in the image. The viewer wants to see the essence of the model's personality, not the details of the wood backdrop. The horizontal framing hides the details of the subject's hair, shoulders and cleavage...all qualities that both men and women are interested in.

Keep at it.

May 12 18 01:15 am Link

Photographer

Philip Brown

Posts: 568

Long Beach, California, US

MC OConnor wrote:
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/170801/02/59804ecaa1689_m.jpg

okay, im a noob, but.. I still have artistic sense wink

To me, there's something off about the face. I think there's something about the mass of hair covering the left side of the face, that makes (our) right side, look abnormally large. That's unattractive in my book.

IMO would have been better with face turned more directly towards camera.
(edit: or as Gus said, maybe its just the lightning making her face look too flat. or both)

May 18 18 11:27 am Link