Forums > Critique > Critique of my amateurish port?

Model

Charlie82

Posts: 15

Rochester, New York, US

At the risk of being pummeled, I'm interested in some feedback on my port and comments on any images that strike you, both good or bad.

My goal was to try to create different looks, locations, backgrounds, etc.

I know it needs lots of work but feedback will help the next time I work on new images and I know the selfies need to go.



Thanks

Aug 11 21 03:52 pm Link

Photographer

Mark Salo

Posts: 11732

Olney, Maryland, US

"Jetski  fun"

I love your big, bold, black bars:
https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/210204/13/601c61b7411ac_m.jpg

But where is the Jetski?

Aug 11 21 05:11 pm Link

Photographer

Francisco Castro

Posts: 2630

Cincinnati, Ohio, US

Charlie82 wrote:
At the risk of being pummeled, I'm interested in some feedback on my port and comments on any images that strike you, both good or bad.

My goal was to try to create different looks, locations, backgrounds, etc.

I know it needs lots of work but feedback will help the next time I work on new images and I know the selfies need to go.



Thanks

Hire an actual photographer with knowledge of lighting, composition, and the technical aspects of photography. What you have currently isn't so much a portfolio, but more of an iPhone camera roll.

Aug 12 21 12:12 pm Link

Photographer

Garry k

Posts: 30130

Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada

You have a Good Strong Look and probably could get some Real Work as a Commercial Lifestyle Model ( i wrote this before i read your bio )

But You will need Professional Photos

Aug 12 21 10:17 pm Link

Photographer

Fleming Design

Posts: 1380

East Hartford, Connecticut, US

Charlie, I agree with the earlier posts that you could get commercial work.  But... your port is terrible.  Most of your shots are 7 years old.  And 6 of the 7 year old photos are of you posing in front of dramatic wall art that diminishes your presence.  Other shots are equally pointless.  Those things do not help you.  Be smarter.

Aug 14 21 08:52 am Link

Photographer

LA StarShooter

Posts: 2733

Los Angeles, California, US

http://www.lamodels.com/EricRutherford shows what a middle-aged model's portfolio ,who books campaigns,  looks like. Rutherford is a working model with LA models. Presentation is everything. If he had your approach to modeling, he wouldn't get bookings. No one would know him.

As for "commercial?" No. There's nothing there. You don't care. So, I don't.

Aug 14 21 10:13 am Link

Photographer

JT Life Photography

Posts: 624

Toronto, Ontario, Canada

Modelling is ultimately about Money - and it is a competitive marketplace - so one needs to approach it seriously.

You have way too many images! You are starting your modelling journey so dispose of all but 4 of the absolute best.

Then search 'standard model poses for men' and use as a guide for expanding your port.

Nobody cares about your pets, marital state or hobbies - those are images for IG or FB, not a model's port, dump them.

Remember you are trying to sell yourself so eliminate anything that isn't razor sharp and focused on you.

As others have written get yourself some professionally shot images - it is an investment.

Good luck,
JT

Aug 18 21 09:04 am Link

Photographer

LnN Studio

Posts: 303

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US

You had a pretty good self critique in your opening comment,
Four good professional phots are better than a lot of poor "Camera roll" shots if you are serious about booking shoots

Aug 22 21 09:12 pm Link

Photographer

FIFTYONE PHOTOGRAPHY

Posts: 6597

Uniontown, Pennsylvania, US

Charlie82 wrote:
[snip] and I know the selfies need to go.



Thanks

Then why do they remain, other than to scream unprofessional.

Aug 25 21 05:36 am Link

Photographer

Brian K Donnelly

Posts: 265

Mathews, Virginia, US

You've had some pretty clear and consistent replies, so I'll try not to pile on. 

"My goal was to try to create different looks, locations, backgrounds, etc."  Not really.  Your goal was (or should have been) to get bookings.  That is what portfolios do...or don't.  You might feel that a bunch of different looks will get you more bookings, and you'd be right, but only if the images you use are of suitable quality. 

Rule #1:  Never post anything but excellent photos.  You can't make up in volume what you lack in quality.  If your portfolio only had one image in it, and it was good, you'd get bookings.  And with bookings, you get more quality images.  On the other hand, sully a few good images with a bunch of sub-par snapshots and photographers will consistently pass you by.   Your portfolio is your visual calling card.  Putting a less-than-excellent image in your portfolio is like putting a typo on your calling card.  Enough on that. 

A fundamental question here is: can you model?  Yeah, sure.  Probably.  That is, if you learn how.  You work hard on your physique, and it shows - that's an asset.  But modeling is more than flexing.  Learn how to pose, practice expressions, know your angles (you'll hear models say that all the time!).  Learn what makes a flattering masculine pose, and what doesn't.  Some specifics:

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/1 … 7471ea.jpg
Nope.  Awkward, does nothing for you.

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/2 … 7411ac.jpg
Bad angle, and bad expression.  Riding a jetski can be fun and exciting, but that doesn't translate at all in this image. 

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/2 … 845f98.jpg
You already noted the selfies have to go.  Yes indeed.  Right this very minute.  The longer they stay there the faster your model cred tanks.  The caption is "Beautiful summer morning", but that doesn't describe this image at all.  Maybe it was, but that's just the weather report.  The image is a grumpy guy at a small family beach.  Nothing works here.

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/2 … 0d76e5.jpg
You'd like this to be good enough to use in your portfolio...but it's not even close to usable.  Shoot the look again, get it right, and you'll have something to use.

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/2 … 10ad1c.jpg
You wear a suit well.  So put on a suit and do a proper shoot.  Including snapshots of your personal life events says you don't have any credible images shot by a pro.  (btw congratulations on 25 years!)

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/1 … f2a2e2.jpg
Ok, this is closer to where you want to be.  Expression!  What's the vibe you're trying to portray?  If I had to guess, you're waiting for your wife outside a boutique and you're watching someone who is about to hit a light pole while attempting to parallel park.  Every image has to have something to say.  Your expression is key (and the guns irrelevant).

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/1 … 778674.jpg
Still watching that car trying to parallel park.  The jeans and shoes aren't helping.  You're not a model here, you're my next door neighbor.

https://photos.modelmayhem.com/photos/1 … 08825e.jpg
Better...you have a good smile.  Now you need to use it well, in the context of a better pose, and a better composition.  Avoid cropping images at the joints (wrists in this case).  The lines of the forearms (being lighter tones than the wardrobe) draw the views eyes to your crotch.  The overall composition ends up with a "moderate" on the creepy scale.

At this point you have a portfolio, which is better than not having a portfolio.  You have the looks and physique that can get you bookings, but you don't have the images that will compel a photographer to book you.  You say in your profile that you want to portray the older CEO type.  Fair enough, you can pull that off.  First clean out your portfolio and approach this from a quality-first perspective.  Put on a suit and go do a proper shoot.  Pay for it.  Use no more than 3 images from that shoot in your portfolio.  Then book with someone else, put on a different suit, go somewhere else (an urban setting where CEOs are found) and shoot again.  Use 2-3 images.  Carry on.

Last point:  rewrite your profile to be more assertive and CEO-like:

At 57, 6'3" and 218 lbs, I'm an ideal fit for commercial and editorial shoots that call for a professional/executive look.  I'm an avid (sports reference), and work out daily to make sure I'm always ready to shoot and represent your project well.  I'm open to most lifestyle, fashion, and fitness looks.  My rates are reasonable, and as time permits I'm open to TFP for creative and intriguing concepts. 

I hope some of this helps.  Stick to it.  Good luck,

Aug 25 21 09:20 pm Link

Photographer

Studio NSFW

Posts: 783

Pacifica, California, US

It's shame there isn't some sort of College where photographers go for technical training in Rochester, NY....

I don't think Photography was ever a big ting there...

/sarcasm

Aug 31 21 12:54 pm Link

Model

Charlie82

Posts: 15

Rochester, New York, US

Thanks for the feedback, especially the  detailed explanation of specific photos.

I do appreciate the constructive criticism

Sep 01 21 07:18 am Link